When I first heard Porcelain and the Tramps, I wanted to grab everyone I saw by the lip and pour her songs into their ears. Porcelain and the Tramps was just Alaina Beaton, some lyrics and heavy industrial music she wrote and played herself. I couldn’t get enough. When I heard Alaina had finally landed a record deal, I couldn’t wait to hear new music and to finally have a polished version of the songs I’d downloaded from a friend who’d most likely downloaded it from a friend who downloaded it from a friend… You get the picture.
After waiting something like six years, she’s finally releasing singles… under the name Porcelain Black. Her first single, “This is What Rock ‘N’ Roll Looks Like,” came out a few months ago, and her second single, “Naughty Naughty,” “leaked” a few days ago. Before “Naughty Naughty” came out on YouTube, a three-song teaser “leaked” as well, featuring “Mannequin Factory,” “La Di Da Di,” and “Love Someone.” We were promised that her next single was coming out soon, so I listened to the teaser a few times and hoped that it wasn’t any of the three.
It’s not that I hate the teaser songs. I don’t hate them. I just don’t like them. They’re catchy and I find myself singing them all the time… but they’re not the Porcelain I’m used to, which is definitely the biggest part of the problem. I thought we were getting a more polished version of Porcelain and the Tramps when she landed this record deal, but it’s obvious that we’re getting the polished, pop version of Alaina.
That’s not the whole problem, though. The song “La Di Da Di” from the teaser goes like this:
La di da di da di,
we like to party
I know you hate it ’cause I flirt with everybody
La di da di da di,
we just wanna party
It’s all about fun and games until I hurt somebody
It’s the second song in the teaser; skip to 1:14.
I thought it was catchy, in a mindnumbing pop-y way, but fun in a guilty pleasure sort of way.
When her single was “leaked” — and I say so with quotes because she and producer RedOne have made it pretty obvious that it was an accidentally-on-purpose, because-we-love-you leak — I couldn’t get to my laptop right away and my phone refused to play the video for some reason, but I had a funny feeling that the “Naughty Naughty” single was the same as the “La Di Da Di” snippet I’d heard. I’ll let you take a listen.
The lyrics?
Naughty, naughty, naughty,
we like to party
I know you hate it ’cause I flirt with everybody
Naughty, naughty, naughty,
we just wanna party
It’s all about fun and games until I hurt somebody
I don’t like being tricked. I mean, I guess it was pretty obvious that the three teaser songs were probably going to be singles, but I really thought we were getting to hear something different.
My third issue with this song is how shallow and flimsy it is, albeit a good dance tune. “We just wanna party?” Compared with the lyrics to, say, “The Preying Mantis,” it just falls flat. Take a listen:
To visually compare, here is the chorus:
I hung you on a limb
made you bend over
backwards on a sin
quit crying on my shoulder
there’s nothing left to say
we’re beautiful garbage
throw it all away
wash you off in the shower
I love Alaina’s voice. I love her lyrical talent. I love her musical talent. I feel like all we’re getting out of this Porcelain Black deal is her voice, and even then I feel like she’s a lot less aggressive on these songs than her Porcelain and the Tramps songs. If it wasn’t obvious after hearing Lil’ Wayne* on her first single that this is not at all the same deal, it’s pretty obvious now.
I can only hope that she’ll release a polished CD of her Porcelain and the Tramps songs as she promised, and while I’ll definitely be picking up her currently untitled Porcelain Black album, I don’t think I’ll ever like it as much as I love her PATT songs. She has so much potential. I hate to say it, but it’s being wasted; I feel like she would be just as successful — if not more — if she went with her earlier style.
I guess I’m just horribly disappointed, but I can’t really complain. It happens all the time.
*Do not get me started on that. I know they’re friends, and I’m sure he’s a nice guy, but… seriously?



