Back in 2004, when I was fifteen, I spent a lot of time on LiveJournal writing about my life and feelings. (I also posted entirely too many quizzes and memes, which is why I think I’m sick of them now.) I logged in daily and read my friends list — ye olde feed reader — even if I didn’t write anything. At first, the people on my friends list were people I knew and had met face-to-face, or people who I knew through those people. Slowly but surely, I started to add people I hadn’t met but shared similar interests with.
One of those people was Saul. Saul had a lot of medical issues. If I remember correctly, he had a severe heart defect. Whatever it was, Saul was always in and out of the hospital. I had only had him on my friends list for a while when I read a post on his LJ that sounded an awful lot like a suicide note. The next thing I knew, one of Saul’s friends posted a comment on my LJ to tell me that Saul had ended his life.
It hurt, mostly because it made me — someone who thought about suicide constantly — think about how suicide affects the people around you. Some time after Saul died, I became friends with his online boyfriend Mathias, who I interchangeably called Mat or Mattie. Mattie told me that he suspected Saul was actually a girl named Becky, who had pretended to be a boy and then committed “suicide” before. I was shocked. How could someone do something like that? Mattie said he couldn’t prove it, but he thought “Saul” was the same person. He also told me that there was another girl who did the same thing, a girl named Ryn.
Mat was a few years older than me, but he sort of became an online big brother. I called him “aniki,” the Russian word for brother. When I had problems with my then boyfriend, or parents, or depression, Mat was there. He was almost always on AIM, and if not, was an email away. He read all of my LJ posts and often gave me really helpful advice. We were friends online for quite a while when we started talking about being pen pals. I asked my mom for permission to exchange addresses with Mat, and when she said yes, I was ecstatic; I was going to have a pen pal in the UK!
Mat and I exchanged many letters and emails over the years. Sometimes, I felt suspicious that he was actually a she, but I kept telling myself to stop being silly. After all, Mat had been duped by Becky, and someone who had been played that way surely couldn’t be playing me. Mat started dating and then moved in with a guy named Charlie, who had a three-year-old daughter named Emily. Mattie was originally from Russia, and didn’t really get along with his parents. He was, in some ways, one of my best friends.
In September 2006, Mat suddenly stopped talking to me. His last email to me was to tell me his new address because he’d finally gone back to school, after previously dropping out. We had sent a few back and forth, and they were all friendly and like our normal emails, so I didn’t at all understand what happened. I guess I assumed he just got busy with school, and didn’t have much time to get online to talk to his “American little sister,” even though he was on AIM a lot but never responded. He didn’t answer any of my emails, and every time we were both on AIM, he ignored my IMs. I sent him the following email in September 2007:
k so, i have this feeling that you are ignoring me. and that’s fine,
although i’m not sure i understand why. but that is your decision. if you aren’t ignoring me.. well, i’ve sent you email after email, tried messaging you on aim today, and still haven’t gotten a reply. plus (and not to sound like a silly high school girl:) i
noticed either you didn’t add my new livejournal or you
unfriended it. so, i guess i really have no other conclusion to make. i was pretty worried about you, but since we were both online just a while ago and you didnt make any effort to answer me back, i guess i can just assume you are ignoring me and that we are to go our separate ways.although i do not understand this sudden decision, i wish you all the best. we have been friends for a very long time, but i guess people just eventually have to go their separate ways. take care of yourself, aniki.
I never got a reply.
Yesterday, while I was reading through my old LiveJournals, I stumbled upon Mat’s old LJs. I hadn’t thought about him in a long time. I had long forgotten his last name, so I could never look him up on Facebook or anything, but last night while reading his LJ, I saw that his last name was Kiovich. I decided to Google his full name, just for hahas to see if I could find him.
And guess what I found? I found this. In the sixth paragraph of the very top entry, dated September 23rd, 2005, is this little gem:
Everyone I seem to know online really likes me, or rather, Mathias. No one loves ME.
I reminded myself that it was entirely possible I was reading someone else’s journal, so I kept reading. And then I found this. I very distinctly remember when that happened. I used to spell “Liz” with an “S” in those days. I started a vampire RPG and my co-moderator got Mat’s game application before I did, and she was disgustingly rude to him. I read some more and discovered that the “Mat” person is actually a she, not a he — not a gay guy just a few years older than me, but a confused girl just a few years older than me, who desperately wanted to be accepted. There was no “Charlie” or “Emily,” but a giant group of friends at her college, two parents, and a bunch of siblings. She had an ex-boyfriend named Roz. There are also several references to Becky and Ryn. I think she is Russian, but everything else “Mat” told me was a lie. I don’t even know her real name.
It makes me sad, that this girl felt like she had to make up an entirely different person to be accepted. “Mat” had his own LiveJournal that was updated almost daily. That must have been a lot of work: writing two LJs, roleplaying and chatting with me and who knows how many others on AIM, and keeping up with her school work. I realize that the Mat character existed before I met “Saul”/Becky, but I still feel kind of betrayed. “Mat” was my friend, someone I thought I knew. I think I could have been friends with this girl, based on her real LJ, but I have no idea how I would have reacted if she had confessed. I wish she had, though, because it came out anyway, years later, all because of a quick Google search. (Interestingly enough, if I Google “Mathias Kiovich” now, that LJ doesn’t come up at all, even though it did last night.)
This whole experience hasn’t ruined my trust in my other online friends, but it does make me sad. At the same time, though, it reenforces my own morals and values as a blogger; what you see of me online is exactly who I am. I haven’t made up any of it. I’ve never felt the need to. I share pieces of myself because I love the connections made in this digital world — especially the blogosphere. Even the scariest things I’ve shared have resulted in at least one great conversation or friendship.
Apparently there are many girls who pretend to be boys online. The comments in this confession are all of girls who just wanted to have fun. Most of them ended up in romantic relationships with other girls. Some of them are sexually confused. A few of them actually confessed to their online girlfriends. This woman actually met with and did sexual things with her online girlfriend. I couldn’t find anything about girls pretending to be gay guys, but I’m sure there are more; after all, there was Becky and Ryn.
I don’t hate “Mat.” I feel bad for her. I wish she had been real with me, because I think that could have been a lasting, no-pressure friendship, rather than her stressing herself out living a double life, as I imagine. I do hate that this is a common thing, and that people are emotionally scarred because of the lies they are told. Online dating has never been and never will be for me, but it is for some people, and it’s sad that you just never know what you’re really getting — even if you’re online and just trying to make friendships. This digital world can be treacherous, but there are also a lot of good, real people — and I’m very thankful for my good, real online friends.
Have you ever been friends with or dated a guy online who turned out to be a girl? Have you ever pretended to be someone you’re not?
I think the closest I’ve ever gotten to pretending to be someone else is those times when I “adopt” someone else’s personality for a little so that I can be more brave, or more social, or more whatever, in a situation. I guess, in a sense, I do kind of become someone else when I’m writing stories, but I would never purposely pretend to be someone else and deceive another person.
